When a sprained wrist puts pro-shortstop Carter Ramsey on the bench just days after being named Citizen Magazine's Man of the Year, he has every intention of enjoying some much needed R&R in his Manhattan penthouse. But when Carter's twin sister tells him his high school sweetheart is newly single, just in time for his 10-year reunion, Carter heads back to his home town with the hopes of winning back the one girl he never really got over. Standing in his way? His ex's stubborn older sister and his former lab partner, who's every bit as annoying as Carter remembers.

Not much has changed since Olive Dunn's days as the mouthy, awkward outcast of Haven High. She's still mouthy, still awkward, still at Haven High (though as a teacher these days), and still wildly protective of her pretty, sweet-natured younger sister. Olive knows the last thing the romantic-minded Felicity needs after her recent divorce is the return of the high school boyfriend who broke her heart. Carter Ramsey was a pain in Olive's side in high school even before he got involved with her sister, and he's only gotten more obnoxious-and better looking-with age. As if Olive doesn't have enough to deal with in co-chairing her high school reunion, now she's got to keep the former prom king as far away from her vulnerable sister as possible.

That Carter's back in town is unacceptable. That he's renting the house next door to Olive is unfathomable. That Olive might be falling for the charming jock? Completely, utterly unavoidable.

Rebellion is a thing of the past for Adeline Blake. As New York's premier event planner, she's all about reform and respectability. Then she's approached by Robert to organize the party of the season. Curious, considering he's her father's most formidable opponent. And alarming, too. Because Addie can't help but fall for the righteously popular candidate with the movie-star smile.

Now it's Robert's choice. Does he pursue a future that holds his legacy? Or the woman who holds his heart?